Home Publications Presidential Fellows Works Recent Presidential Studies Quarterly Articles The Contextual Presidency: The Negative Shift in Presidential Immigration Rhetoric

The Contextual Presidency: The Negative Shift in Presidential Immigration Rhetoric

by  Damien Arthur and Joshua Woods.

Article Abstract

Party platforms from 1993 through 2008 show a positive approach to immigration policy. Presidential rhetoric, however, does not match the tone of the platforms. There are negative frames (illegality, criminality, terrorism, and economic threats) in nearly 50% of immigration speeches. We argue that social context motivates presidents to talk about immigration negatively. This analysis provides insight into rhetoric as responsive to context rather than a mechanism of power. We coded each speech on immigration from Presidents Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama, and found statistically significant results that show that immigration rhetoric is more negative when certain social conditions are present.

 

To purchase this individual PSQ article, click here.